Climate ErrataIndependent, reproducible checks of climate papers, datasets and code

← Register

NOAA hourly precipitation dataset (HPD)

Our write-up on Zenodo (latest version)datasetSignificance: High

Finding

Step at the 2012 digital upgrade (~+9–10% in hourly maxima)

VerdictReal error (instrument step)
SignificanceHigh (Size 2 · Reach 2 · Consequence 1 = 5 of 6)
Basis: +9-10% step in hourly maxima, larger than trend signal (S); NOAA HPD feeds Atlas 15 (R); exposure traced, not fully rerun (C)
OutcomePublished
Where reportedZenodo preprint
Our write-up on Zenodo (latest version): doi:10.5281/zenodo.24327949
Date2026-11-17

Summary

NCEI's COOP Hourly Precipitation Data (HPD v2) comes from Fischer & Porter weighing gauges that were converted from punched-tape recorders to digital loggers, mostly in 2012. At each station's conversion, hourly maxima jump by about 9–10% relative to the co-located daily gauge, which shows no change. The step is not flagged in the dataset, and it is as large as the trends that sub-daily studies report.

What we found

SeriesStep at conversionp
GHCN-Daily annual maximum day (independent gauge)+0.3%0.90
HPD annual maximum hour ÷ GHCN max day, raw 0.01 in+9.1%0.014
Same, with legacy-resolution emulation (cumulative 0.1 in)+9.9%0.008
HPD maximum daily sum ÷ GHCN max day+5.3%0.006

The preprint also reports the step in the 15-minute data and its effect on the frequency of heavy hours.

Who is affected

Any analysis that uses HPD hourly or 15-minute data across the conversion years: sub-daily trend and scaling studies, non-stationary intensity–duration–frequency work, and NOAA Atlas 15. How much a study is affected depends on how it handles resolution: coarsening each hour to 0.1 in can hide the step, while native or cumulative resolution keeps it.

Response

The NOAA Atlas 15 team was told on 17 November 2026; no reply yet. The preprint has been revised once at an author's request (version 3 corrects how one paper's data screening is described).

What users can do

Locate each station's conversion date from the source flags (provided with the preprint code) and test for, or adjust, a step at that date. Compare with co-located daily gauges.

Reproduce

Preprint and code: doi:10.5281/zenodo.24406978 (version 3; all versions: 10.5281/zenodo.24327949). Data: HPD v2 from NCEI (doi:10.25921/p7j8-2170) and GHCN-Daily.

Discussion

Questions and discussion are welcome: ask other readers, the authors or the maintainer. Authors and developers are especially welcome to reply. Comments use GitHub Discussions (sign in with GitHub). No GitHub account? Write to us.

Found a new error? Please tell the authors or data producers first, or report it to us privately. New error claims posted here may be hidden until the responsible party has been contacted. Posting policy