Climate ErrataIndependent, reproducible checks of climate papers, datasets and code

← Register

NASA MERRA-2 corrected precipitation (PRECTOTCORR) over Australia

ConfirmeddatasetSignificance: High

Finding

About a 20% dry step from 2016 in PRECTOTCORR over Australia, inherited from the CPC Unified gauge analysis (CPCU) that MERRA-2 uses to correct land precipitation. CPCU's own gauge-count field shows Australia lost about 95% of its gauges in two steps (2007–08 and 2015–16, e.g. E Australia ~590 → 90). GPCP and GPCC do not show the step, and a gauge-independent reanalysis (NCEP R1) confirms it sits in CPCU.

VerdictReal error (input-data step)
SignificanceHigh (Size 2 · Reach 2 · Consequence 1 = 5 of 6)
Basis: ~20% step in a continental precipitation series, larger than trend signals (S); MERRA-2 is a major reanalysis, PRECTOTCORR forces land and soil-moisture products (R); developers confirmed, no rerun of published work (C)
OutcomeConfirmed
Where reportedEmail to NASA GMAO (M. Bosilovich, R. Reichle); confirmed by Reichle. MERRA-2 is frozen and will not be changed; MERRA-21C and SMAP L4_SM v6+ no longer use CPCU; to be noted in the MERRA-21C validation documentation
Date2026-11-20

Summary

MERRA-2 corrects the precipitation that reaches its land surface (PRECTOTCORR) towards the CPC Unified gauge analysis. Over Australia, CPC's gauge input collapsed in 2015–16, and its analysis became about 20% too dry. MERRA-2 PRECTOTCORR tracks CPC to within 1–4% in every year, so it inherits the step, and with it everything the land model computes from that rainfall: soil moisture, runoff and evaporation.

What we found

Period (Australia, 115 cells of 2.5°)CPC / GPCPMERRA-2 / GPCP
2000–060.9650.959
2007–141.0571.051
2016–250.8050.825

Who is affected

Any use of MERRA-2 land hydrology or PRECTOTCORR over Australia across 2015–16: drought and soil-moisture trends, runoff, land-surface anomalies, and PRECTOTCORR used as "observed" rainfall. Users of the CPC Unified analysis itself over Australia are affected in the same way. Papers that use the affected data are listed below.

Response

We wrote to NASA GMAO (Michael Bosilovich and Rolf Reichle). Rolf Reichle confirmed the finding. MERRA-2 is a frozen system and will not be changed; GMAO's newer products, MERRA-21C and SMAP Level-4 soil moisture (v6 and later), no longer use CPC Unified over Australia. GMAO will note the issue in the MERRA-21C validation documentation.

What users can do

Reproduce

MERRA-2 M2TMNXFLX v5.12.4 monthly PRECTOTCORR (GES DISC, Earthdata login), land points with FRLAND > 0.5, aggregated to GPCP 2.5° cells over 44–10°S, 112–155°E; CPC Unified daily (NOAA PSL) with its gauge-count field; GPCP v2.3 monthly. Scripts are available on request.

Discussion

Questions and discussion are welcome: ask other readers, the authors or the maintainer. Authors and developers are especially welcome to reply. Comments use GitHub Discussions (sign in with GitHub). No GitHub account? Write to us.

Found a new error? Please tell the authors or data producers first, or report it to us privately. New error claims posted here may be hidden until the responsible party has been contacted. Posting policy